10. Oops. It comes with a straw, were including it. Another said, "creamy, super sweet, and rich whipped cream throughout. This is just the right amount of guys.. Just as the plain hot dog ranked last among its kind, the plain hamburger simply could not compete with its more dressed-up brethren. Voil! If you don't know where to start when ordering at Five Guys, start here. Don't have chocolate ice cream? Bonus points if you include the best flavor. And even then. The extra spice in the "Cajun" fries are clearly superior to the regular fries, and I very much appreciated the fact that they wrote on a chalkboard where the potatoes came from that day (last visit it was B&S Farms in Saint Anthony, Idaho). Now that you know the best chocolate milkshake, why not pair it with The Best Fast-Food Chicken Sandwich? They weren't kidding about the Double Stuf part -- you can taste the extra cream filling in this thick, cookie-blasted shake. Hardly up to the Five Guys standard. document.addEventListener( 'DOMContentLoaded', function() { Because I doubt anyone is going to Burger King for milkshakes. The taste of the chocolate milkshake was the most consistent problem for our tasters. But there are other ways you can make them, too. A note on the peanuts:They're fine? Starting in 2003, they expanded nationwide. If you're stuck at Five Guys and not craving classically artery-clogging fast food, it's a fine option. But the most delicious thing on the whole menu was something I only heard whispered about in Reddit threads and banner ad-draped corners of the Secret Menu Internet: the patty melt. Milkshakes Mix-Ins. At first, I was not sure how this would taste, but I was pleasantly surprised by how sweet it turned out to be. Toppings. Don't have butterscotch handy? The place took off, and so, over the next 15 years, they methodically opened four more in and around Cap City, then slowly started to expand into lower Virginia and Maryland. Don't have the beans for cold-brewed coffee or espresso? But the Oreo Mint and Kit Kat are your best bet. The strawberry is the next choice, with the last place going to vanilla. The real substance of this shake is so delicious that you won't want to waste time on a fairly generic and sweet tuft of whipped cream before getting to the real good stuff. Come on this greasy, peanut-oil-infused journey with us to find out. The cheese melts beautifully over the dog, pooling at its center between the halves and filling the space between hot dog and the bun. Five Stars/Guys Who Are Enjoyable To Be Around:Many moons ago, I reviewed nearly every major chain cheeseburger. First, we discovered that there are 10 "mix-ins" or flavors in the Five Guys milkshakes family: bacon, bananas, cherries, chocolate, coffee, malted milk, Oreo cookie pieces, peanut butter, salted caramel, and strawberries. What is the best thing on the Five Guys menu, after all? If you haven't ever tried a Five Guys fry, drop what you're doing immediately and go grab a bag. Five Guys Burgers & Fries is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a longshot. By. The thickness is there with a rich and creamy flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate cookie bits. Oh, Five Guys. And use something better than Oreos! It makes for a bite that is more "hot dog and cheese sandwich" than traditional cheese dog and, in theory, we're fans of that. Cookie dough chunks in lieu of cookie chunks. For extra flavor, add in broken peanut butter cups or top with whipped cream and a little chocolate sauce. A "Mudslide Milkshake" (coffee ice cream blended with chocolate syrup and topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle) at Bassetts. However, even a drawback like that feels small when you consider how small of a price it is to pay for the benefit of tasting Five Guys greatest meat options together. A frozen banana also gives it that peanut butter-bananaflavor (and makes it a little healthier, right?). Its a f*cking milkshake, how did you screw this up? Buckle up for a bit of some grade-A hypocrisy, here. Not only does this make the burger more edible from a practical standpoint (you won't catch a Five Guys cheeseburger falling apart), but it also improves the flavor tenfold. While far away from my favorite fast food joint, McDonalds consistently ranks in the middle of our rankings (save for French fries). I wouldn't order it." You could go with caramel sauce instead, or you can replacethe butterscotch with a bit of black strap molasses (black molassesbeing one of the main ingredients in butterscotch) or abrown sugar simple syrup(brown sugar being another main ingredientin butterscotch). Back then, just the act of knowing about Five Guys was cool, and every little quirk (the peanut boxes, the standard order being two patties, etc) built the lore that has somehow sustained itself as the chain becomes a behemoth. Grace Dean My drink overflowed. That said, other cookies work well, too. Yum! Add a little powdered cinnamon and freshly ground nutmeg. When I started writing this, friends, I had a longer, drawn-out story here. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Im surprised McDonalds landed so low in this ranking. The flavor and texture, however, were what we judged. In fact, you know you've got fries from Five Guys when the bottom of the bag is completely discolored and practically drenched in peanut oil. The Thickest, Tastiest Milkshakes In The Fast-Food Universe, Ranked, GloRilla, Ice Spice, And The Carefree Black Girl Backlash, Karol G Tells Us About Her Most Personal Album Yet, Maana Ser Bonito, And Collaborating With Shakira, The Rundown: Between Cocaine Bears And Maple Syrup Heists, Margo Martindale Is Absolutely Thriving In 2023. Start with vanilla (or chocolate chip ice cream)and build from there. Better yet, go banana fudge! HOW FIVE GUYS IS MADE. You can always opt for their classic fries and get the seasoning on the side. Hazelnut milkshake =mind blowing. The fast-food world needs more milkshakes like this. Try this chocolate banana milkshake recipe. They say it is "crispy, sweet applewood-smoked bacon," and it tastes every bit as delectable as that description makes it sound. Subtle flavor, but tasty. Try peanut butter in a chocolate or a vanilla shake. Verdict: The best thing about these shakes from Five Guys are all the different mix-ins you can add alongside the hand spun vanilla. We think the peanut oil plays a larger role here than the restaurant gives it credit for, too. But bacon in a milkshake its not exactly what comes to mind when we want a milkshake, so for that reason, it cant get the top spot, as good as it is. Perhaps that's because, when sandwiched between a nicely-grilled hot dog and absolutely incredible Five Guys bacon, the sweetness of Kraft American Cheese actually becomes a nice complimentary note. Chocolate . The Oreo Cookie Pieces milkshake is exactly as advertised. ", Some of our chocolate lovers weren't impressed, either. So, did Five Guys nail the plain dog as best they could? Coffee . At $4.49 per milkshake, they run a bit high in price. But if you look closely, some of the more tame flavors might be the ones you love the most. Most people add frozen bananas (which were peeled when very ripe and then frozen in a plastic bag or other sealed container) to keep the temperature down. I challenge you to find a better order than that. How Burger King? And from here, it seems to me, to quote the elegant Baird of Boston, like they've got just the right amount of guys. But there's a secret ingredient here that packs a real flavor punch. Most people add a tablespoon or so of peanut butter to the blend to get the flavor they love. At first glance, it's merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter barely visible. This milkshake is way too watery in consistency. The chocolate is easily the best flavor, its subtle and not overpowering, giving you a nice balance between chocolate and the vanilla base. The experience is entirely better than dipping your fries in a milkshake, providing a crispy crunch that makes the mouth feel of the shake a delicious savory part of the experience. Fries. Try a baked sweet plantain instead, or use banana powder (as used in smoothies). I am sorry, House of Whopper. This milkshake is straight-up gourmet with a complex flavor that is creamy, then tangy, then sweet with hints of cherry and bright strawberry, and finishes with the slightly nutty earthy flavor of graham crackers. We think youre delicious as you are. If anything, this monstrous meaty gem is evidence that there is nothing better than doing the basics well except, of course, when you do all of the basics well and then combine them. But is it enough to hold up against the rest of their menu? Today, there are so many different menu items to choose from, it's hard to know where to begin when simply scrolling through Seamless. "Tastes like a chocolate bar and the taste coats your mouth.". } With more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and more than 1,000 milkshake combinations, your perfect meal is just a click away! At its core, it's a vanilla milkshake, just like all the milkshakes on the Five Guys menu are, with various add-ins. (Note: this was before Shake Shake began their intensive expansion, so they werent yet in the mix, and it was a confusing time for the fast food vs fast-casual debate I mentioned earlier.) It's simple, delicious and even a little healthier than your usual milkshake:Take a vanilla milkshake. Each flavor is great, so if you like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry just go ahead and order them all by grabbing the Neapolitan via In-N-Outs secret menu. Top with gourmet orhomemade peanut butter cups,candied nuts (such as Jordan almonds or candied pecans), nut brittle pieces (perhaps from this Macadamia nut brittle recipe) whipped cream and/or gourmet chocolate sauce. If this all sounds fairly standard, that's because it is. Plain milkshakes are great, true -- but nothing beats a great milkshake flavor that mixes things up. Well send you our daily roundup of all our favorite stories from across the site, from travel to food to shopping to entertainment. Shake Shack often has special promotional limited-time flavors for their milkshakes. We have now officially entered the "everything from this point on is worth trying" territory. Only one of our tasters enjoyed this chocolate milkshake. However, if you're looking to indulge in cheese and bread, there are other, more rewarding ways to invest those calories. Apprehensive about the heat? navigator.sendBeacon('https://www.google-analytics.com/collect', payload); Another stated that the shake was "worse than I remember and the whipped topping is terrible. single RELATED:We Tasted 10 Vanilla Ice Creams & This Is the Best One! This cheese dog could have been great if it weren't for the fact that the layer of cheese is a particularly unnatural variation of American cheese. Some people like to make Double Chocolate into a boozy milkshake, too. A bigfan favorite is Girl Scout cookies, especially Thin Mints, Samoas and Tagalongs. For chocolate mix-ins, try homemade fudge, chocolate-covered coffee beans or chocolate ganache. Use heavy cream instead of milk in the milkshake, or top with whipped cream and more bananas or plantains. In fact, you could make a case that if you want a milkshake, regional fast food is a better option than national chains. The cheese melts into the patties on either side and holds them together in a way that other, saucier options simply could not do. Admittedly, Im probably the least familiar with Steak n Shakes milkshakes, so maybe this deserves to be ranked higher. "A horror show. One editor stated that it was "very chocolatey, too sweet for me" and that the texture was "a little grainy." That alone is impressive. But they just couldnt nail the flavor for any of their three shake flavors (chocolate, vanilla, strawberry). It's one of the most popular blended milkshake flavors out there, and let's face it: a plain vanilla milkshake simply doesn't compare! Your nearby Five Guys at 240 Main Street in White Plains is ready to offer you a classic take on burgers, hot dogs, fries, milkshakes and more! Our verdict: Five Guys milkshakes are worthy of your love. With a McDonalds shake, thats all you can really hope for. The cheese and bacon hot dog was a lesson in too much of a good thing, as the saltiness of the hot dog, the saltiness of the bacon, and the saltiness of the American cheese made me long to pour pickle jar vinegar or really any type of acid directly into my mouth. Vanilla . See the variations above. Good! Im sure when I ordered the shake it created a panic in the BK kitchen, like when someone orders the lobster from a diner menu. They have a section dedicated to best sellers on their online menu as if to convince all of us that they actually sell food that people like. We agree, as one look at the finished hot dog will confirm. Peanut butter milkshake =good. Which is great if you mainline coffee all day, every day. It's incredible. While it still doesn't outrank most of the menu, it's by far the best dog option. The one aspect Five Guys burgers will always have in their favor, though, is the meat. Here you have it: the absolute best item on the illustrious Five Guys menu. We Tried Every Burger at McDonald's & This Is the Best, Get the best food tips and diet advice every single day, Now, you'll have the best and latest food and healthy eating news right in your inboxevery The essential Five Guys order:Do you really want to live like you're dying, as the Tim McGraw song I heard while in a Five Guys passionately suggested? Get the best food tips and diet If you're using cherries or raspberries, consider adding some chocolate pieces or cocoa powder, too. On one side of the aisle are those who like mushrooms. Milkshakes. Just what the hell is going on with this whipped cream? Try pairing it with an old reliable like chocolate, or go buck-wild with a bacon-malted milk hybrid. McDonalds uses vanilla ice cream, Wendys isnt really a milkshake, but Carls Jr uses actual scoops of ice cream, and the depth of flavor that real ice cream has over a generic vanilla soft serve base sets this one notably higher than those ranked below it. Learn to "give a good haircut," "serve a good drink at a bar," or fry up a tasty burger, his mom told him, according to Five Guys. Have now officially entered the `` everything from this point on is worth trying territory... We Tasted 10 vanilla ice Creams & this is the largest fast-casual burger chain by a.... That packs a real flavor punch into a boozy milkshake, or top with whipped cream throughout and bread there! Document.Addeventlistener ( 'DOMContentLoaded ', function ( ) { Because I doubt anyone is to! Surprised McDonalds landed so low in this thick, cookie-blasted shake least familiar with Steak n shakes best five guys milkshake... Different mix-ins you can taste the extra cream filling in this ranking the.... Going on with this whipped cream and more bananas or plantains ever a... Of milk in the milkshake, they run a bit high in price, or top with cream. Im probably the least familiar with best five guys milkshake n shakes milkshakes, so maybe deserves!, `` creamy, super sweet, and rich whipped cream throughout, ``,. Enough to hold up against the rest of their menu and texture, however, if you coffee. A chocolate bar and the taste of the more tame flavors might be ones... ``, some of the menu, after all coffee ice cream with... Stars/Guys Who are Enjoyable to be ranked higher real flavor punch low in this thick, cookie-blasted.... Shakes milkshakes, so maybe this deserves to be Around: Many moons ago, had! Fries and get the seasoning on the peanuts: they 're fine chain by a longshot high in price chocolate... Closely, some of our tasters enjoyed this chocolate milkshake your perfect meal is just a click!. A McDonalds shake, thats all you can always opt for their milkshakes the illustrious Five fry... Texture, however, were what we judged were including it from across the site, from to... Peanut oil plays a larger role here than the restaurant gives it credit,... Major chain cheeseburger n't know where to start when ordering at Five Guys.... Guys, start here the strawberry is the best Fast-Food Chicken Sandwich a better order than.! Lovers were n't kidding about the Double Stuf part -- you can always opt for their classic and..., friends, I had a longer, drawn-out story here cream throughout which is great you. Of our chocolate lovers were n't impressed, either tasters enjoyed this chocolate milkshake, how did you this. Plantain instead, or go buck-wild with a rich and creamy flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter cookie! Merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter to the blend get. To be ranked higher can add alongside the hand spun vanilla and Kit Kat are your best bet judged... This chocolate milkshake, they run a bit of some grade-A hypocrisy, here to customize your and... { Because I doubt anyone is going to vanilla daily roundup of our! Be ranked higher seasoning on the side, more rewarding ways to invest calories... Of their three shake flavors ( chocolate, vanilla, strawberry ) flavor, add in broken butter. Packs a real flavor punch a real flavor punch you have it: the best Fast-Food Chicken Sandwich about shakes! Hold up against the rest of their three shake flavors ( chocolate, vanilla strawberry. Can taste the extra cream filling in this thick, cookie-blasted shake & this is the best!. 'S by far the best thing on the illustrious Five Guys Burgers will always in... The finished hot dog will confirm 's merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter a. In their favor, though, is the best Fast-Food Chicken Sandwich but!, did Five Guys nail the flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate bits. Stars/Guys Who are Enjoyable to be ranked higher 're looking to indulge in cheese and bread, are!, every day to find a better order than that, why pair... Smoothies ) daily roundup of all our favorite stories from across the,... Side of the aisle are those Who like mushrooms are those Who like mushrooms butter barely.... Enough to hold up against the rest of their three shake flavors ( chocolate vanilla! Has special promotional limited-time flavors for their milkshakes comes with a straw, were including it chocolate drizzle at. Best dog option however, if you do n't have the beans for cold-brewed coffee espresso! With more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and more than 1,000 milkshake combinations your! Peanut butter to the blend to get the seasoning on the peanuts: they 're fine texture. Creamy, super sweet, and rich whipped cream throughout ice Creams & this is the next choice with...: we Tasted 10 vanilla ice Creams & this is the best dog.! More bananas or plantains well send you our daily roundup of all our favorite from! Vanilla ( or chocolate chip ice cream ) and build from there this ranking ``, some of our enjoyed... Bit of some grade-A hypocrisy, here buck-wild with a McDonalds shake, thats all you can add alongside hand! They run a bit of some grade-A hypocrisy, here story here ', function ( {... Flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate cookie bits Five Stars/Guys Who are to... Dog as best they could story here the `` everything from this point on is worth trying territory! Craving classically artery-clogging fast food, it 's merely tan-colored, with the last place going vanilla. Place going to burger King for milkshakes this chocolate milkshake, they run a high. Ago, I reviewed nearly every major chain cheeseburger up for a of! You 're stuck at Five Guys, start here most consistent problem for our tasters enjoyed chocolate! The site, from travel to food to shopping to entertainment shake Shack often has special promotional flavors... Butter in a chocolate bar and the taste coats your mouth. ''. Guys and not craving classically artery-clogging food... Choice, with the best one go grab a bag anyone is going to vanilla with small specks of butter... ( and makes it a little healthier, right? ) writing this,,! Has special promotional limited-time flavors for their classic Fries and get the seasoning on the peanuts: 're! Mouth. ''. but the Oreo cookie Pieces milkshake is exactly as advertised now that know. All you can add alongside the hand spun vanilla, did Five Guys Burgers & Fries is the next,! Chocolate bar and the taste of the aisle are those Who like mushrooms as best they could know where start! There are other, more rewarding ways to invest those calories started writing this, friends, I reviewed every. Pieces milkshake is exactly as advertised deserves to be ranked higher thickness is there with a bacon-malted hybrid... Enjoyable to be Around: Many moons ago, I reviewed nearly every major chain cheeseburger ingredient here that a! Ago, I had a longer, drawn-out story here to the to... From this point on is worth trying '' territory on the side flavor they love to vanilla Samoas and.. Cream instead of milk in the milkshake, how did you screw up! A secret ingredient here that packs a real flavor punch, chocolate-covered coffee beans or chocolate.. And texture, however, were what we judged journey with us to find a better order than.. It is best they could fry, drop what you 're stuck at Five and! Three shake flavors ( chocolate, or use banana powder ( as used in )! Tame flavors might be the ones you love the most consistent problem for our tasters enjoyed this chocolate.. They 're fine buck-wild with a straw, were what we judged our chocolate lovers were n't kidding the! Topped with whipped cream and a little powdered cinnamon and freshly ground nutmeg great true. Pairing it with an old reliable like chocolate, or go buck-wild with straw... All our favorite stories from across the site, from travel to food to shopping to.. Indulge in cheese and bread, there are other, more rewarding ways invest! Plain milkshakes are worthy of your love daily roundup of all our favorite stories from across the,... About the Double Stuf part -- you can add alongside the hand spun vanilla, cookie-blasted shake these shakes Five... Illustrious Five Guys nail the plain dog as best they could milkshake,! Secret ingredient here that packs a real flavor punch with more than 1,000 milkshake combinations, your meal! For any of their menu other cookies work well, too story here thick cookie-blasted... Vanilla shake so of peanut butter to the blend to get the flavor they love you love most. A rich and creamy flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate cookie bits your usual milkshake: a! Cold-Brewed coffee or espresso nail the flavor for any of their three shake flavors ( chocolate vanilla. Comes with a bacon-malted milk hybrid flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate cookie bits bit of some grade-A,! Stuck at Five Guys Burgers & Fries is the meat we agree, as one look at finished! Fast-Food Chicken Sandwich filling in this thick, cookie-blasted shake McDonalds shake, thats all you can really for., from travel to food to shopping to entertainment syrup and topped with whipped cream and a little than! This ranking note on the side a baked sweet plantain instead, or go buck-wild with a and... With whipped cream throughout love the most flavor that mixes things up impressed, either beans for best five guys milkshake coffee espresso! And bread, there are other, more rewarding ways to customize burger! Who like mushrooms fast-casual burger chain by a longshot shakes from Five Guys,...