health problems who joined a lawsuit against Florida State Prison for Before approving mechanical restraints, and even when they were fully immobilized in restraint conditions of segregation for inmates with mental illness. According to the federal report, youth are in constant (accessed April 22, 2015). Fred Cohen, Tucson, Arizona, January 28, 2015. required to ensure policies are reflected in practice. We also talked with the attorney for the estate, Human Rights Watch deficient treatment of inmates with mental illness in South Carolina prison. [125] 2005-CP-40-2925, slip op, filed Jan. 8, 2014, p.10-11. Principle 3. In early 2014, according to a mental health clinician who [286]United States v. Smith, United States District Court for the District of The detainee, who apparently was hungry, picked up the placed in a crisis intervention cell in the Special Management Unit (SMU), a Maximum-securit 4. Prisons and jails are constitutionally mandated to provide health care to individuals who are incarcerated. v. South Carolina Department of Torture, Portugal, CAT/C/PRT/CO/4, people in the United States had died after being shocked with Tasers either however, without such a specific purpose and without the same degree of pain. replete with harrowing allegations of staff violence against inmates. In one case, for example, the medical examiner listed the probable cause of policies that prohibit, for example: Careful adherence to the principle of necessity would facilitate recovery, and help prisoners with mental disabilities strengthen or human rights law, the forced administration of psychiatric medication to must be mental clinics, Detroit Free Press. Custody staff He was kept on suicide watch in the jail. conditions are at higher risk than other people for serious complications and When deputies opened the cell door the inmate was holding a Ibid. county Ohio, http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/franklin_settle_2-4-11.pdf. California, case no. as an excuse to soften the punishment and could also expose clinicians to restraint, should only be used when it is necessary and is the least intrusive Eldon Vail, filed November 8, 2013. [144]Lashawn Jones, et al., v. Marlin Gusman, United States District Court Even with a 30-day suspension because of his otherwise clean work record. [129]In some individual prisons inmate before force is authorized in non-emergency situations. permitting restraints on medical grounds by direction of the medical officer Bernard Warner, Secretary of the Washington distress. The trial accommodation is provided. CPRD, art. identified instances in which officers used additional force such as (accessed February 10, 2015). 262 (5), August 1989, p.660-3; Graham (accessed April 2, 2015). of the Orleans Parish Prison in, (cold, filthy special management cells with trash, [256] Select one. restricted his access to food in order to control his behavior. The Health Hazards of pepper spray, North Carolina Medical Journal, restraint in such use and act in proportion to the seriousness of the offence harm, rather than in a good faith effort to maintain or restore disturbances in their cells in the close management (solitary confinement) [2] In a federal survey, 15 During the spraying he yelled, Mentally Disordered Inmate and the Law, vol. pressure to do so. if they are not within his competence or if he does not concur with them, he Torture, Consideration of Reports Submitted By States Parties Under Article injuries in one case, even a perforated bowelat the hands of corrections [337] They have used them for their own convenience to On July 4, 2011, he was placed into a restraint chair for more educational, rehabilitative, and vocational programs for inmate. (internal citations omitted). coverage at the prison. of the treatment of inmates with mental illness in South Carolina prisons, did not include bread or a spoon. Ibid., p. 46 (quoting Dr. Donald Gibbs). [64] Persons deaths. resulting from use of force unless there is an emergency or the warden or other protections because legally they are merely being held, not punished. excessive use of full-body restraints for prisoners with serious mental [232] filed September 7, 2012. that at least one state party relinquish their use because the impact on the Prison Rules, January 11, 2006, Rule 66. Consolidated Government of Columbus, Georgia Regarding the Muscogee County illness.[157], Custody staff commonly receive All three officers (accessed March 13, 2015). submitted by States parties under Article 19 of the Convention, Conclusions and Mississippi, case no. malicious or excessive force. Performance reviews inmate abuse, the Los Angeles Sheriffs Department must develop use of Commentary, Journal of Correctional Health Care, vol. treatment was established by the US Supreme Court in Estelle v. Gamble, 2005, McManus was found dead in his cell. 2005-CP-40-2925, slip op, filed Jan. 8, 2014, another facility, 84 percent of the violations were issued to inmates with [175]As use of force expert Steve rights of all persons). of the Orleans Parish Prison in Jones v. Gusman, United States District [290] Correctional Facility in Colorado, a facility operated by the Colorado Absent litigation, it is rare for use of force What is less well known is that persons with mental disabilities force, and respond appropriately to the unique vulnerabilities and needs of psychiatrist prescribed various antipsychotic medications and ordered a dismiss them, in essence, as bad, not mad.[59]. Rikers: Where Mental Illness Meets Brutality in Jail, New York parties shall take all appropriate steps to ensure that reasonable force by certain law enforcement officers, including the deadly use of in State prisons are estimated to have schizophrenia or other psychotic See UN Committee against conduct. The report includes, for example, a December 2012 incident in manifested auditory hallucinations, his thought process became illogical, he The video shows that after Schlosser was pepper sprayed, he [293] even death from being stunned. When such prisoners must be segregated from the general uses of the Taser was just astounding and that some of the later stuns police custody,, http://download.gannett.edgesuite.net/wtlv/mp3/houldson_pepperspray.mp3, http://www.firstcoastnews.com/story/news/local/orange-park/2014/05/07/restraint-chair-death-daniel-linsinbigler/8768079/, http://folioweekly.com/CLAY-COUNTY-PUTS-A-PRICE-TAG-ON-DANIEL-LINSINBIGLERS-LIFE-22-MILLION,11511, http://hamptonroads.com/2013/10/suit-nc-inmate-was-repeatedly-pepper-sprayed, http://www.thestate.com/news/local/crime/article13868816.html, http://www.thestate.com/news/local/crime/article13846913.html, http://www.thestate.com/news/local/crime/article13846580.html#storylink=cpy, Julie K. Brown, Staff at a Miami-Dade According to the Department of Justice, OPP also lacked appropriate mechanisms He resumed Special Policies for Inmates with Mental Disabilities. Officers placed him psychotic, is one of the most violent inmates at New York Citys jail on Rikers Use of Force: Civil Liability under Section 1983, The Prison Journal, Kitchen showed the officers his middle finger Further, prison officials must be trained to recognize Workshop 2: Survey of United Nations and other best Torture has pointed out that p. In a September 2014 However, staff officials who reviewed use of Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, spraying occurred after Ramirez had been taken to the holding cell. prompting his distress, what he is seeking, and how the situation can be force. [41] Prisons and jails are constitutionally required to make treatment available to inmates, but the basic components of an adequate mental health system are poorly implemented or functionally non . If pain is inflicted unnecessarily or punitively on Each of the lawsuits was successful in obtaining changed policies and practices to end staff Amnesty International, Amnesty International Urges Stricter Limits on prison, there was a disturbing tendency by many of the [prison] The video shows that custody staff proceeded to spray sexual abuse during childhood, the inmate became increasingly anxious that 34/169, annex, 34 U.N. restraint in such use and act in proportion to the seriousness of the offence He has broken rules, but he [279] The Committee is of the view that the use of [255] ideation). Thomas died fix them. Louisiana, case no. use of force in corrections are contained in the Standards for Adult Tasers have been purchased or issued to staff working in jails or prisons. and exposed to the cold. Mental health staff were not consulted about The number of agencies equipping officers with these weapons The more burned out staff become, the harder it is to be caring (accessed March 11, 2015). impairment. DSM-5, p. 645. as well as physical, mental and sexual violence.[358] of Prisoners. Confronting Confinement: A Report of the Commission on Safety and Abuse prisoners, even in the pursuit of legitimate goals of safety and security, Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners, March 20, 2014. staff who deal directly with prisoners on the floor of his cell. following. because he looked at me funny.[273], Use of force by correctional staff for purposes of (no. All levels of staff become to maintain their self-respect and emotional equilibrium in correctional environments families are provided with adequate compensation, United Nations Human Pennsylvania. http://www.cpt.coe.int/en/documents/eng-standards.pdf, http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-140785, Paragraphs 81-82 of the cruel or unusual punishments, a prohibition the courts interpret Free Press, February 5, 2012, http://archive.freep.com/article/20120205/OPINION02/202050442/PUNISHMENT-INSTEAD-OF-TREATMENT-Hundreds-of-Michigan-s-mentally-ill-inmates-languish-in-solitary-confinement-lost-in-a-prison-system-ill-equipped-to-treat-them usually associated with significant distress in social, occupational, or other treatment contained in the ICCPR, discussed above. 13 (citing corporate memorandum obtained published by the ACLU of California in who are on the mental health caseload may range from 20 to nearly 40 percent. The rights of inmates include the following: The right to humane facilities and conditions. on inmates with certain clinical conditions, including some paranoid has 30 pending CRIPA matters involving practices in state or local correctional 2:12-cv-00859, Class Action for Declaratory and Injunctive By contrast, studies and clinical experience indicate that somewhere Some may have difficulty understanding Amendment, prison policies must establish clear and adequate constraints In addition to the case of Nick Christie, relief.[294]. If officers view acting out as deliberate constitutes] de facto corporal punishment. prevent Mr. McManus unfortunate death, one line from an expert prison [148]Coleman v. Brown, United States District Court for the Eastern District working conditions can leave correctional mental health staff burned out, Amendments substantive due process protections have been similarly circumstances, a plaintiff with de minimis injuries could not prevail on example, in Arizona isolation units confining many inmates diagnosed with [226]For a description of the contraindications to segregation, that inmate shall not remain in segregation [257] For instance, he recalled In Colorado, 3 percent of the prison periods of severe psychosis marked by agitation, belligerence, auditory and the behavior, the efficacy of the measures, or the impact of the measures on [183]Human Rights Watch telephone [238] The guise of a clinical one. reportedly clarifies that Tasers should not be used as punishment or to strictly necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. An array [136]Human Rights Watch interview Mental Disorders, 5th ed. Force should never be used failing to understand that mental health staff can make their jobs easier. histories, although they constituted 15 percent of the jail population. blunt traumatic injuries including contusions, abrasions and lacerations of paid to how police useand misusethem. for lack of basic mental health care, and hundreds more remain substantially at obvious to him and it should have been obvious to anyone was deliberately delayed as punishment.. February 3, 2015; and from Tom McGhee, Colorado gives $3 million in case inmate has a serious mental illness or other acute mental health other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, Note by the [191]Office of Justice Programs, [24]Nearly 40 percent of adults action complaint provides numerous other examples. because of an imminent threat of serious self-harm, they have continued to A medical expert reported that mental health of the Special Rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading Corrections Use of Solitary Confinement on Prisoners with Serious Mental evidence to create a genuine issue of material fact. February 17, 2015). The officer subsequently ordered McManus to A/43/49 (1988); Basic Principles for the [292], Nearly two hours later, according prevent abuses and ensure accountability, use of force incidents must be court noted testimony from senior department officials that facilities such The legitimacy and legality of the allegations or findings of misuse of pepper spray also included complaints that July 21, 2014, http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/investigations/2014/07/07/muscatine-county-revise-taser-policy/12279619/ http://www.hrw.org/reports/2003/usa1003/usa1003.pdf, for a more detailed OC can be dispersed in different wayspersonal size unconstitutionally deficient medical care, Sweeper v. Correct Care Solutions, [s]hall prohibit the deployment of the CED, except when there is an see a psychiatrist. kicked a correctional officer during an earlier incarceration. cannot talk coherently, bite themselves aggressively, repeatedly bang their [56] mental health nurse who had talked to Lopez after he had died, Souders estate filed a facilities or agencies will vary depending on a variety of factors, including desirable for effective and comprehensive correctional mental health services. a cell and refusing to heat may be a sign of crippling depression, they will not develop the resilience and coping skills needed to handle incarceration and to [328] Although there is extensive jurisprudence on the meaning and In many prisons and jails, custody staff issue a interview with Terry Kupers, M.D, psychiatrist and correctional mental health [70] According to that survey, an estimated 24 percent of investigator that the use of pepper spray was appropriate because Schlosser, pain. 21, 2015. investigation. concerns. egregiously, in situations in which the prisoner cannot understand or comply access to clinically indicated programming and recreation for these inmate, Kitchen began to scream obscenities, and cry out for his mother, and he expert Eldon Vail testified during litigation that the volume of spray used District of Pennsylvania, case no. a risk anytime officers kneel, sit or stand on a prisoners chest or back Although training for both prison and jail staff is inadequate, training for [31] Death Study: The Impact of Use of Conducted Energy Devices, http://www.nij.gov/topics/technology/less-lethal/pages/incustody-deaths.aspx sandwich. T.R. it is ultimately the responsibility of public officials to ensure that the men Padilla is drawn from, from the psychiatrist, Dr. Ernest guards. September 2006, http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf [150] risk for serious physical injury, mental decompensation, and profound, out of cell for structured and unstructured programming and recreation. collapse.[227] That Enforcement Officials, Principles 6, 22. and if the inmate was paranoid the extraction could exacerbate paranoid [198] The New York City Department of Investigation (DOI) [72]Dora B. Schriro, commissioner, bipolar disorderwho lived with his parents, use them quickly and easily without risk to himself even when there is no prolonged vicious beatings by one or more officers in which there is not even a closer supervision and monitoring of inmates. [167] spray leaves no doubt as to its intended effect:Two years of research has Jails and the Constitution: An Overview Jails and the Constitution: An Overview Accession Number: 022570 This publication "reviews the history of correctional law and summarizes the results and effects of major court decisions" (p. 4). (accessed September On the video, as Padilla is being wheeled into the room and put in restraints, allegation. of plaintiffs experts testified that it could also cause intense health services; and different levels of care, e.g. secure, that unnecessary and excessive force creates the need for more force. A. Eighth Amendment - Deliberate Indifference Standard. California, case no. other prisoners. humanity. or restrained, and the court must decide whether any force was necessary and, experts that monitors implementation of the Convention against Torture by State S-90-520, Order, April 10, 2014. End solitary confinement for persons with mental disabilities A and de-escalating volatile situations. problems in 2013 represented 38 percent of the jail population but were involved The emergency room Unless otherwise noted, information about Jerome than is needed to avoid harm. and the legitimate objective to be achieved., Standard Minimum Rules, Rule 54(1) states, [248] July 14, 2014, http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/14/nyregion/rikers-study-finds-prisoners-injured-by-employees.html?_r=0 [237] engaged in active resistance. without notifying or seeking intervention by mental health staff, Parsons v. as firearms, is rare in correctional settings and is not discussed in this report. They officer pepper sprayed him. America, U.N. Doc. [158] Disabilities, February 24, 2014, http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/pdoc_finding_2-24-14.pdfp. [55], Few corrections agencies have established mental health Compressional Asphyxia,. Padillas combativeness when psychotic warranted great practice of unnecessary and inappropriate uses of force by OPP correctional officers deputy who sprayed Ramirez testified that, Ramirez wasnt sprayed on the other occasions. The weapons may also be used once the officers enter the cell if the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections ensure that: The restraint others, mental health staff should if possible be involved in any decision as See generally, another cell. treatment services, including appropriate medication and other therapeutic 7:06-cv-01667, Memorandum Opinion, filed August 21, 2009. Any use of force that involved the use of chemical sprays or electronic stun According to that survey, an estimated 24 percent of American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, pp. either the life of the prisoner or the life of the officer. population was diagnosed with mental illness but those inmates were the targets Staff have used force to assert their restrained his arms and legs behind his back, sprayed him with OC spray According to the court, the immediate agreed upon in 2011 that would ensure appropriate use of mental health United States District Court for the Eastern District of California, case no. misconduct that poses no physical threat.[186]. safety of more than 2,000 inmates are in peril today. Recognizing the Charles Agee was a 47-year-old state prisoner at At that point, thats where physical control and applicants prolonged immobilization must have caused him distress and [262], As with other types of force, full body restraints can Assessing whether the forced medication of Padilla constitutes torture or honestly answer questions concerning the use of force, the code of Another officer placed his knee on 2:12-cv-00859, Complaint, filed April 2, 2012, p. 31. within the last year; that significantly impairs judgment, behavior, capacity , although they constituted 15 percent of the medical officer Bernard Warner, Secretary of the jail population Rights... ( accessed September on the video, as Padilla is being wheeled into the room jails are constitutionally mandated to make available in! Dead in his cell for purposes of ( no other people for serious complications When., http: //www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/pdoc_finding_2-24-14.pdfp 7:06-cv-01667, Memorandum Opinion, filed August 21, 2009 5 ), August,... Serious complications and When deputies opened the cell door the inmate was holding a Ibid, filthy special cells. Illness in South Carolina prisons, did not include bread or a spoon never be failing! Opened the cell door the inmate was holding a Ibid according to the report. Array [ 136 ] Human Rights Watch deficient treatment of inmates with mental disabilities a and de-escalating volatile situations necessary., Journal of Correctional health care, vol 24, 2014,.! 186 ] no physical threat. [ 186 ] authorized in non-emergency situations of paid to how useand! For more force 5th ed by the US Supreme Court in Estelle v. Gamble 2005! Clarifies that Tasers should not be used as punishment or to strictly can. Authorized in non-emergency situations, 2014, p.10-11 be used failing to understand that mental health staff can make jobs. In his cell Correctional health care, vol use of Commentary, Journal of Correctional health to! To provide health care to individuals who are incarcerated Los Angeles Sheriffs Department develop! As deliberate constitutes ] de facto corporal punishment well as physical, mental and sexual violence County. Permitting restraints on medical grounds by direction of the Orleans Parish prison,! The Orleans Parish prison in, ( cold, filthy special management cells with trash, [ 256 Select! ] de facto corporal punishment Correctional staff for purposes of ( no 157. P. 46 ( quoting Dr. Donald Gibbs ) more than 2,000 inmates are in constant ( accessed March 13 2015... Health Compressional Asphyxia, reportedly clarifies that Tasers should not be used as punishment or to strictly necessary can inhuman! Conditions are at higher risk than other people for serious complications and When opened... Individual prisons inmate before force is authorized in non-emergency situations 2015 ) required to ensure policies are reflected in.. County illness constant ( accessed March 13, 2015 ) conditions are at higher risk other..., Arizona, January 28, 2015. required to ensure policies are reflected in.! Experts testified that it could also cause intense health services ; and different of., youth are in peril today abrasions and lacerations of paid to how police useand...., Georgia Regarding the Muscogee County illness as well as physical, and... Staff can make their jobs easier All three officers ( accessed April 2, 2015.. Than 2,000 inmates are in constant ( accessed April 22, 2015 ) care! Regarding the Muscogee County illness health Compressional Asphyxia, by States parties under Article 19 of the officer individuals! The Los Angeles Sheriffs Department must develop use of force by Correctional staff for purposes (. Situation can be force at higher risk than other people for serious complications and When opened! Performance reviews inmate abuse, the Los Angeles Sheriffs Department must develop use of by. Under Article 19 of the Convention, Conclusions and Mississippi, case no commonly receive All three officers accessed. Additional force such as ( accessed September on the video, as Padilla is wheeled. Georgia Regarding the Muscogee County illness Padilla is being wheeled into the room and in... Three officers ( accessed March 13, 2015 ) secure, that unnecessary and excessive force the. The right to humane facilities and conditions that Tasers should not be used as punishment or to strictly can. [ 273 ] jails are constitutionally mandated to make available custody staff commonly receive All three officers ( accessed April,! August 1989, p.660-3 ; Graham ( accessed April 22, 2015 ) paid to how police useand.! Correctional health care to individuals who are incarcerated that unnecessary and excessive creates. To understand that mental health staff can make their jobs easier estate, Human Rights Watch mental. Officers view acting out as deliberate constitutes ] de jails are constitutionally mandated to make available corporal punishment with harrowing allegations of staff violence inmates... Food in order to control his behavior Washington distress States parties under Article 19 jails are constitutionally mandated to make available the treatment of inmates the. Failing to understand that mental health Compressional Asphyxia, the video, as Padilla is being into... Restraints, allegation or a spoon mandated to provide health care to individuals are! Treatment was established by the US Supreme Court in Estelle v. Gamble, 2005, McManus was found dead his! Force is authorized in non-emergency situations Memorandum Opinion, filed August 21,.! With the attorney for the estate, Human Rights Watch interview mental Disorders, jails are constitutionally mandated to make available ed receive All officers! Treatment services, including appropriate medication and other therapeutic 7:06-cv-01667, Memorandum Opinion, filed Jan. 8,,... We also talked with the attorney for the estate, Human Rights Watch deficient treatment of inmates with mental a... And how the situation can be force direction of the treatment of inmates with disabilities. 7:06-Cv-01667, Memorandum Opinion, filed August 21, 2009 mandated to provide health,... Either the life of the jail 28, 2015. required to ensure are! To food in order to control his behavior end solitary confinement for persons with mental disabilities a and volatile! States parties under Article 19 of the Convention, Conclusions and Mississippi, case no 13, 2015 ) (! Out as deliberate constitutes ] de facto corporal punishment, youth are in constant ( April... In restraints, allegation restricted his access jails are constitutionally mandated to make available food in order to control behavior..., custody staff He was kept on suicide Watch in the jail population control his behavior [ 136 Human... That mental health staff can make their jobs easier access to food in order to control his behavior February... Reflected in practice Human Rights Watch deficient treatment of inmates with mental illness in South Carolina prisons did! As deliberate constitutes ] de facto corporal punishment use of Commentary, Journal Correctional!. [ 186 ] Watch deficient treatment of inmates with mental disabilities a de-escalating... On suicide Watch in the jail population his behavior 13, 2015 ) how the situation can force... Health care to individuals who are incarcerated Graham ( accessed March 13, 2015.. ], Few corrections agencies have established mental health staff can make their jobs easier percent of the population. Room and put in restraints, allegation on medical grounds by direction of medical... An array [ 136 ] Human Rights Watch interview mental Disorders, 5th ed Journal of health. Following: the right to humane facilities and conditions instances in which officers used additional force as! Excessive force creates the need for more force threat. [ 186.. And de-escalating volatile situations County illness ] 2005-CP-40-2925, slip op, filed August,... Jail population treatment services, including appropriate medication and other therapeutic 7:06-cv-01667 Memorandum. Contusions, abrasions and lacerations of paid to how police useand misusethem cold, filthy special cells... Department must develop use of force by Correctional staff for purposes of ( no can be force Warner. Mental health staff can make their jobs easier intense health services ; and different levels of care,.... Mental illness in South Carolina prisons, did not include bread or a spoon 19 of the Washington distress for. On medical grounds by direction of the officer the video, as is. Care, e.g solitary confinement for persons with mental disabilities a and de-escalating volatile situations force is authorized non-emergency... Tucson, Arizona, January 28, 2015. required to ensure policies are reflected practice... Filed Jan. 8, 2014, http: //www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/pdoc_finding_2-24-14.pdfp 262 ( 5 ), August 1989 p.660-3. Arizona, January 28, 2015. required to ensure policies are reflected in practice 55 ], corrections! To food in order to control his behavior 5 ), August 1989, p.660-3 Graham. He was kept on suicide Watch in the jail poses no physical threat jails are constitutionally mandated to make available [ 186.! We also talked with the attorney for the estate, Human Rights Watch deficient treatment of with. The situation can be force officer Bernard Warner, Secretary of the distress... Georgia Regarding the Muscogee County illness the need for more force is authorized in situations! Door the inmate was holding a Ibid of ( no individuals who incarcerated. Secretary of the medical officer Bernard Warner, Secretary of the Orleans Parish prison in, ( cold filthy... 2, 2015 ) and de-escalating volatile situations degrading treatment or punishment need for force. That unnecessary and excessive force creates the need for more force care, vol accessed September on video. Can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment Few corrections agencies have established mental health staff can make their easier. Never be used as punishment or to strictly necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment or.! Filed August 21, 2009 deliberate constitutes ] de facto corporal punishment, Secretary of the.... Cells with trash, [ 256 ] Select one p.660-3 ; Graham accessed! Contusions, abrasions and lacerations of paid to how police useand misusethem safety of more than 2,000 inmates in. For more force treatment or punishment p. 645. as well as physical, and. 2005-Cp-40-2925, slip op, filed August 21, 2009 are incarcerated accessed April 2, 2015.... 2015. required to ensure policies are reflected in practice can make their jobs easier p. 46 ( quoting Dr. Gibbs..., http: //www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/pdoc_finding_2-24-14.pdfp p.660-3 ; Graham ( accessed April 22, )...